New York Chopped Cheese Sandwich

New York Chopped Cheese Sandwich

The Chopped Cheese sandwich (aka "the chop cheese") originated in New York, and has spread to every corner of the country. Here's the recipe with a southern twist, so you can make your own at the next family BBQ.

Head over to our YouTube Channel to see Kosmo make this delicious (and CHEAP!) sandwich with a little ASMR thrown in - WATCH NOW!

You Will Need

The Prep

If you're from (or have been in) New York, you might have seen the Chop Cheese sold in one-stop stores all over Manhattan, the Bronx, Brooklyn, or Queens. It's a simple yet effective sandwich, grilled on a griddle, and served wrapped in sandwich paper.

So, let's get the prep work out of the way. While your griddle is heating up, spray with some Duck Fat cooking spray (or a drizzle of vegetable oil).

While that's coming up to temp, season the patties with Texas Beef and Garlic Jalapeno on both sides, and set aside. Half, peel, and slice the onion finely. Thinly slice tomato as well, and shred the iceberg lettuce (or get pre-shredded from the grocery store).

The Cook

Once the griddle is hot, throw on the patties. Sprinkle with an extra coat of Texas Beef before flipping for the perfect crust! Cook for 1 minute, flip, cook for another minute, then flip again.

Grab a chopper/spatula and start chopping meat horizontally into long strips. Use the spatula to hold patties in place while you chop. Then add onions to the meat, and keep chopping while you use the spatula to mix the meat and onions well.

Once mixed, form the onions and grilled beef into a pile that mirrors the shape of your hero rolls. Press down firmly with the spatula.

While the meat cooks, toast your hero rolls by using your favorite sandwich presser or on the griddle. To be as close to authentic as possible, try to make grill marks longways!

The Payoff

Toast the rolls to your desired level of toastiness. Now add three slices of American Cheese to each pile of the meat and onion mixture, and leave on griddle until the cheese is melted.

Once your rolls are toasted, remove from the press and slice lengthwise. Don’t cut all the way through the roll! 

Time to assemble your Chopped Cheese sandwich! The original recipe order is as follows: Mayo and ketchup on both sides, then shredded lettuce sliced tomatoes on one side. Use a spatula to place the meat, onions, and cheese mixture on the opposite side of the roll. Finally, fold the two sides together and press firmly. Slice sandwich in half, right down the middle. Wrap in sandwich paper and enjoy!


Submit your own recipe. Embrace greatness.

Have you worked with Kosmos for a while, and come up with something even better? Many of our recipes are submitted by our wonderful customers, who come up with all sorts of ideas that we could never think of.

Go here to submit your own recipe. If accepted, you'll get 10% off the whole store.

Also in Recipes

Overnight Pork Butts on a Pellet Grill

Effortlessly smoke tender, juicy pork butts overnight on your pellet grill. Perfect for no-fuss, delicious BBQ. Wake up to mouth-watering aromas and ready-to-shred pork.

The EASIEST Overnight Pork Butts On A Pellet Grill EVER!

On today’s video, I’m showing you how to make the easiest, overnight pork butt you’ve ever made in your life! For this pork butt, we’re firing up the Traeger with hickory pellets, but you use whatever cooker, and pellets, you want, just make sure it’s ready to run at 225°F overnight. This video is perfect for beginners that are looking for an easy pork butt recipe. First, I’ll show you how I do a light trim, then we’ll apply a mustard binder, rub it up, and set it on the smoker. And, if you don’t want to trim the fat off, you don’t even have to do that! Seriously, it doesn’t get much easier than this smoked pork butt recipe. Even though we aren’t injecting these pork butts, I’ll tell you what I would use if we decided to. And make sure you’re paying attention because I’m showing you exactly how to rack these pork butts for the perfect smoke. Plus, if you’re smoking in the cold, I’ll tell you how I maintain the perfect temperature in my smoker. Once you’ve got the pork butts perfectly placed, shut the lid and don’t touch them for at least 12 hours. When that time is up, I’ll show you how to check the temp, get the perfect wrap, and we’ll finish up the cooking process. Once the pork butts are complete, we’ll shred it, make some killer sandwiches, and what doesn’t get eaten, we’ll store for later. Enough talking, let’s get to cooking.
5 Minute Brisket Chili on a Weber

Transform yesterday's brisket into today's feast with this 5-Minute Brisket Chili recipe! Breathe new life into leftovers for a quick, flavorful, and satisfying meal.

Everyone wishes that they could have award-winning competition BBQ at their backyard barbecue parties. With Kosmo’s BBQ, that's exactly what you'll have, every time.